Nasty Cherry – Shoulda Known Better

TRACK REVIEW: The band’s latest is quintessential Nasty Cherry – but also sadly lackluster.

TRACK REVIEW: The band's latest is quintessential Nasty Cherry - but also sadly lackluster.

For a while, Nasty Cherry was one of the most enigmatic names in music.  The moniker first got on most people’s radar via Charli XCX’s social media accounts.  Charli talked about Nasty Cherry a lot.  But the band didn’t have any music out, so the hype was confusing for most fans.

Of course, in hindsight it all makes sense.  Nasty Cherry is an all-girl pop/rock band formed by XCX as a sort of music-industry-plant-experiment / girl-power music startup.  The band’s formation, songwriting process, and personal dramas were all documented in a Netflix Original Series, also created by Charli.  (It was in this show that drummer Debbie Knox-Hewson casually revealed that she is queer.)

The band’s debut EP was released alongside the first – and so far, only – season of that show, (although three of the five tracks had been previously released as singles).

Nasty Cherry - Season 1 EP. Album art courtesy of Atlantic Records Press

What was frustrating about that release wasn’t that it was bad, it wasn’t, but that it was almost really good.  The songs are basically well-written and they’re definitely stylish, sounding like a bouncier Sky Ferreira.  The whole EP basically fell into the same category – the songwriting, instrumentation and production all sounded correct, but not necessarily very exciting or inspired.

Now, Nasty Cherry is back for another round, releasing the single ‘Shoulda Known Better’.  So far, this second era of music is being released sans-TV-show, but who knows if that will last or not, Season 2 could still be coming.  The single still isn’t bad, and it still sounds like Sky Ferreira – but it also still sounds like the work of a band with potential more than that of a band at their peak.

Nasty Cherry - Shoulda Known Better. Single art courtesy of Atlantic Records Press

It kicks off with some grungy guitars, which are overpowered by some poppy vocals and synths within seconds.  The first verse ends with a genuinely great drum fill that hints at a huge, 80’s-style chorus that unfortunately never materializes.

The mile-a-minute chorus that actually comes instead is an unexpected twist, and it probably seemed like a really fun idea on paper.  In actuality, it feels like a letdown on the preceding build.  It’s hard to not want that huge chorus at some point, but the song ends without it ever happening.  (Oddly, this is the exact same problem that their premiere single ‘Win’ suffered from – drawn out, masterful build with little payoff.)

Nasty Cherry. Courtesy of Atlantic Records Press.

None of this means that Nasty Cherry doesn’t still have the potential to be a really incredible band.  Their ideas are good, and their sound is (almost) as stylish as their Instagram feed.  But it seems like fans will have to wait a little bit longer for them to fully deliver on that potential.

Take a listen to ‘Shoulda Known Better’ here, and then let me know your thoughts in the comment section below!  Do you agree with my assessment, or did I get it all wrong? I wanna know!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.